General News

DOMINATRIX BEATS REGULATOR INTO SUBMISSION

Dominatrix Beats Regulator into Submission; as Ofcom deliver judicious spanking to ATVOD

Published Tue 23rd Feb 2016
By itsAdult / General News

DOMINATRIX BEATS REGULATOR INTO SUBMISSION

"Dear Mr Johnson, You've been rather a naughty boy, haven't you?"

State regulators are seldom challenged in such explicit terms.

Yet this is exactly how artist, dominatrix and provocateur Ms Itziar Bilbao Urrutia responded when the Authority for Television on Demand (ATVOD) had the temerity to suggest that her fetish-themed website and art project The Urban Chick Supremacy Cell (UC-SC) was in breach of their regulatory régime.

In successfully challenging ATVOD's authority, Urritia has delivered a decisive blow for sexual liberties against the forces of repressive regulation and state sanctioned censorship.

The Urban Chick Supremacy Cell

The regulators were at a distinct disadvantage from the outset, since the UC-SC website defies classification artistically and sexually, let alone legally. A disclaimer on the site proclaims that is an "art project designed, produced and created by real life dominant women," wherein "all violence and speech are part of a fictionalized dystopian Femdom fantasy".

Ms Urrutia deploys her subversive wit to deftly deconstruct male fantasies of female domination with the revolutionary call to arms: "No Goddess! No Mistress! No Corsets!" Instead, this traditional iconography is replaced by a Baader-Meinhof inspired terrorist cell chic of bovver boots, balaclavas and brutal bob haircuts. A newspaper cut and paste ransom note typeface proclaims that the UC-SC have been: "Defeating Patriarchy at their own game since 2010". Men are referred to as "banker wankers" and reeducated in feminist theory in the "Meat Dildo Abbatoir" by virtue of Valery Solanas' SCUM Manifesto that "males are emotional cripples".

Well, you were warned that the UC-SC defied classification.

It may be easier to let The Urban Chick Supremacy Cell website speak for itself. It can be accessed via an appropriate disclaimer here:

http://uc-sc-femdom.com/5542disclaimer/ (NSFW)

ATVOD

The infinitely duller ATVOD website claims that:

"ATVOD is the independent co-regulator for the editorial content of UK video on demand services that fall within the new statutory definition of On Demand Programme Services.

Its duties and powers derive from the Communications Act 2003, as amended by the Audiovisual Media Services Regulations 2009 and the Audiovisual Media Services Regulations 2010 which came into force on 19 December 2009 and 18 March 2010 respectively. The Act confers functions on the Office of Communications (Ofcom) for the regulation of On Demand Programme Services, and gives Ofcom power to delegate certain functions to an appropriate regulatory authority.

On 18 March 2010, Ofcom delegated certain of its functions and powers in relation to the regulation of On Demand Programme Services to ATVOD by means of a formal designation".

Yawn.

In this context an "on-demand" video is one that a viewer can choose when they want to view, such as an iPlayer clip, rather than a scheduled television broadcast.

Nonetheless, ATVOD claim that they have the legal authority to act as the official regulator and censor for on-demand video content online; presuming that those videos were produced or editorial control remained in this country and such "programmes" are similar to those usually broadcast on television.

Thus it may seem surprising that a quango should want to pursue a one woman, cottage industry, niche fetish video producer; since broadcast television is sadly bereft of scheduled programmes featuring explicit strap-on pornography.

However, ATVOD benefit financially from on demand video services by charging a "regulatory fee" from those who choose to comply. Hence having gone after bigger adult industry players like Playboy TV, ATVOD seem to have been reduced to pursuing women who produce female domination pornography. A significant number of whom have closed their websites as a consequence.

Censor Driven Moral Panic

Perhaps of greater concern is ATVOD's view of itself as moral guardian, since, ATVOD's Chief Executive Pete Johnson has been quoted as saying that:

"Asking visitors to a website to click an 'I am 18' button or enter a date of birth or use a debit card is not sufficient – if they are going to offer explicit sex material they must know that their customers are 18, just as they would in the 'offline' world."
ATVOD believes that websites should require the user to supply valid credit card details or other personal information that can be cross-referenced with the electoral roll or another ID database, thus establishing the user's identity.

Failure by commercial websites to obtain proof that the user is over 18 before allowing access to adult content is considered by ATVOD to be a breach of the Obscene Publications Act 1959.

Johnson also confirmed that in the case of non-pay sites containing user-uploaded material it is the uploader that is legally responsible rather than the service provider."

In reality this approach delegates responsibility for interpreting parliamentary legislation, namely the Obscene Publications Act, onto financial institutions such as banks and credit card processing companies who come with their own moral and risk aversion to sexual services; rather than organs of the state such as the Crown Prosecution Service who are responsible for drafting the OPA Guidelines.

Hence this undesirable situation has been criticised by, amongst others, The Open Rights Group who called for parliamentary scrutiny of ATVOD's private discussions with financial institutions, last year. To adopt Ms Urrutia's turn of phrase, this means "banker wankers" can exert financial censorship over consensual adult sexual expression.
Legal Backlash against ATVOD

Against this backdrop of regulatory and financial censorship, Ms Urrutia received what she thought seemed an unnecessarily threatening demand from ATVOD and hence immediately contacted sexual liberties campaign Backlash, for whom I provide pro-bono legal advice.

Backlash agreed to fund a barrister specialising in telecommunications regulatory challenges, Ligia Osepciu at Monckton Chambers, to provide provisional advice. Along with my colleague Daniel Godden, a partner at Hodge Jones and Allen solicitors; and in collaboration with Ms Urrutia; we were able to draft ripostes to ATVOD's correspondence.

Unsurprisingly ATVOD returned a determination against the UC-SC, so Ligia drafted the following request to Ofcom to appeal ATVOD's decision:

REQUEST FOR APPEAL OF ATVOD'S DETERMINATION THAT THE PROVIDER OF THE ON DEMAND PROGRAMME SERVICE "THE URBAN CHICK SUPREMACY CELL" WAS IN BREACH OF ATVOD'S RULES 1 & 4 AND THEREBY CONTRAVENED SECTION 368BA AND 368D(3)(ZA) OF THE COMMUNICATIONS ACT 2003

Although we were fully prepared to judicially review Ofcom's decision, our appeal was successful. However, frustratingly, we were embargoed from reporting or discussing that outcome. Until today. Now that Ofcom have published the decision on their website, we are finally free to disseminate this information in public.

Taking the Piss Out of the Regulator

I feel the final the final words should be Ms Urrutia's (who is about become PhD candidate at Birmingham University, partly due to her UC-SC project).

Hence what follows is her hilarious deconstruction of ATVOD's attempt to critique her art project. You are welcome to skip to the end, but you will miss her spectacularly taking the piss out of the censor's attempts to understand Duchamp's Urinal:

"First of all, the artist and creator of the UC-SC project, Ms Itziar Bilbao Urrutia, would like to thank ATVOD and in particular, Peter Johnson, for attempting a critical challenge to the relevance of my work in relation to other contemporary art practices, both contemporary (Relational Art, as I will explain below), and historical (as is Duchamp's Urinal). I'm flattered that institutions outside the art world, such as ATVOD, acknowledge that art has an impact in our culture. Proof that, contrary to the views of its detractors, contemporary art practices play a critical role in society. Last but not least, I welcome the chance to explain my current ongoing project, The Urban Chick Supremacy Cell – UC-SC, and its place within art history, and in particular, how it engages with contemporary art discourses.

"In this case, regardless of the intention behind the website, it does from the user's perspective contain many of the trappings of more "mainstream" femdom sites: there is a standard listing of fetish categories such as 'bondage', 'strapon', 'humiliation' and 'watersports'. ATVOD acknowledges that the service also includes features such as blogs and still images. However, the non-audio visual elements of the service appear to be ancillary to the provision of the programmes available. The content also features on its own Clips4Sale Studio, a standard outlet for pornography; the site advertises reviews with the line 'what the top porn sites and blogs say about UC-SC', and features links to adult sites such as 'Lady Sonia' and 'The British Institution'. "

My project and Femdom adult content website, The Urban Chick Supremacy Cell, is indeed a "real" adult website, that offers real adult content, to real adults, subject to real payment in real currency. It is not a simulacrum in any way of form, nor a representation. As an example of relational art, as formulated by French art critic Nicolas Bourriaud in this seminal 1998 text Estetique Relationelle – Relational Aesthetics (Les Presses Du Reel, 1998). You can read more about Relational Art, here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relational_art

That is an essential feature of Relational Art that sets it apart form more traditional formats: the complete blurring of boundaries between the representation and the object represented. My website is a real adult website, but it also a work of art, operating at several different levels, from the erotic to the theoretical and critical (such as its participating on current feminist debate).

According to Bourriaud:

"relational art produces human relations"

As the UC-SC project clearly does.

Also (from the Wikipedia link above):

"The artwork creates a social environment in which people come together to participate in a shared activity. Bourriaud claims "the role of artworks is no longer to form imaginary and utopian realities, but to actually be ways of living and models of action within the existing real, whatever scale chosen by the artist."
In Relational art, the audience is envisaged as a community. Rather than the artwork being an encounter between a viewer and an object, relational art produces intersubjective encounters. Through these encounters, meaning is elaborated collectively, rather than in the space of individual consumption."

So my website does indeed create a real experience, not a simulacrum of an experience, because it certainly not a simulacrum of an adult website. It has to be real, to give the viewer the opportunity to engage in the "human relation" that Bourriaud writes about. Therefore, it is fully usable by the public, who actively interact with the artwork in ways that link to real life and the real world, away form the conventions of simulacra or "representation" of more traditional art. It blurs the boundaries between the object represented and the piece of art, because they need to be both the same thing, to take the artwork away form the traditional passive role as an artifact to be merely contemplated by an individual viewer. Relational artists create art pieces that are meant to be participatory.

"To look at the service as a whole, and its purpose, we understand that the intention may be that the Service is primarily an art project. (...) You refer to Duchamp's "Urinal", for instance, but if that urinal had been used as a urinal, this may have affected perception of its 'purpose'. It is also possible that a website made available on the open internet does not perform the same role or have the same purpose as a website displayed in a public gallery (as you say this website has been)".
You reply to your suggestion that Duchamp's urinal would be read very differently, and probably cease being perceived as a work of art, if it was reverted to its original use, is a classic argument one hears among first year art undergraduates. Duchamp's urinal, first on foremost, has been urinated on many times over the years, the last one by Chinese performance artists and art saboteurs Cai Yuan and JJ Xi at Tate Modern: http://www.global-contemporary.de/en/artists/53-cai-yuan-a-jian-xi-.

This act didn't change the piece's status as one of the 20th Century's seminal works of art that enabled future generations among which I count myself, to ponder and explore in our work the boundaries and the nature of art. If anything, it proves its ongoing relevance as art. Despite the "defiling", and I presume that after being wiped clean by senior conservation experts and art restorers, it is still being exhibited at Tate Modern.

Yes, my website and art project, UC-SC does indeed serve a practical, or as I prefer to call it, interactive purpose of enabling adults to access videos and photo galleries that function at different level: from an erotic narrative within the conventions of traditional pornography, to a serious reflection within current debates in contemporary art (see again Bourriaud). It's also an ongoing response to concerns within the current feminist debate.

Even though Oscar Wilde claimed that "all art is ultimately useless", 100-odd years after him, current contemporary discourse acknowledges that the artwork can and often has more than one function. Being utilitarian, user-friendly, or interactive, are indeed options asidiously explored by the later generations of artists, among which I count myself. That it can be used, enjoyed, and participated on in more ways than the traditional artwork/viewer found traditionally in art museums and galleries, is one of the basis of much XXIst Century contemporary art.

A perfect example is John Frankland's public art work "Boulder": (http://www.peeruk.org/projects/frankland/john-frankland.html), two granite boulders set on two London parks, that can and are, indeed, regularly used by climbers, just as any boulder found in nature would. A perfect example of the "interactiveness" of contemporary art and how being "the real thing" doesn't stop it from being also an important piece of public art.

You say "that you claimed the website has been exhibited at art galleries". Here is a link to the exhibition Genealogies of Spanish Feminist Art, shown at MUSAC (Museo de Arte Contemporaneo de Castilla y Leon), in 2012 (http://genealogiasfeministas.net/itziar-bilbao-urrutia/), and curated by Spanish at critic Juan Vicente Aliaga. This detail is just anecdotal. Perhaps because I am an artist and not a civil servant, I believe that an art work stands by itself, and doesn't need institutions, nor anybody else, to validate it. However, I pointed at that link to assure you that I am not the only person who recognizes my project The Urban Chick Supremacy Cell - UC-SC , as a piece of contemporary art, and what's more part of a Genealogy (or tradition) of Spanish feminist art.

With all this, I am only replying to your suggestion that there is only one use and purpose to my UC-SC project, the erotic, and that it invalidates any other purposes, intentions or discourses in it. I am very proud of my project, precisely because it works at many levels and I dispute that the possibility that it might be sexually arousing for some viewers, invalidates its artistic purpose or value. The history of art is full of pieces that were considered too sexually explicit or erotic for public view and as we know, what constitutes pornographic is firmly tied to its time, place and specific culture.

It is with sadness that I must turn to more mundane matters. My principal purpose is NOT the provision of programmes. It is to showcase artistic talent, within a distinct political orientation. Now that the technology to both create and distribute videos has democratised conveying artistic concepts for sharing and exchange within communities of interest as Recital 21 puts it, representing this through online videos is a natural way to give expression to these artistic talents. It is why YouTube is so successful. After artistic & political motives, the provision of programmes is merely a means to an end, and certainly not my principal purpose.

I fear you are allowing your personal tastes to influence your judgment. A problem with Authority down the ages.

Mind you, I sympathise with your predicament. Rebuffed in your attempts to regulate the bigger boys, like Murdoch, you need to find some rationale to renew your contract, and what better and more defenceless target than one person efforts with an adult perspective like those of mine and my milieu. After all, you have nothing to lose. Nothing happens to you if Ofcom knock you back. You face no sanctions."

Source: www.mylesjackman.com

You May Like

Mums Make Porn To Air  On March 20th
General News / Sun 10th Mar 2019 Mums Make Porn To Air On March 20th Mums Make Porn is a new show coming to Channel 4 that follows 4 real mums who make a porn film, cast it, direct it and produce it to make the kind of porn they would prefer their children see if they had to watch it. The series follows them through the UK adult business to the UKAP Awards 2018 to the screening of their movie in Londons West End
UKAP Meet and Mix Day Of Events 26th March
General News / Thu 7th Mar 2019 UKAP Meet and Mix Day Of Events 26th March UKAP Meet and Mix Day of events at Sanctum, Soho on Tuesday March 26th
Europe Extends Production Hold Until March 25th
General News / Thu 7th Mar 2019 Europe Extends Production Hold Until March 25th European Alliance extends production shutdown pending results of second test of first gen performers to HIV+ performer
Super Marios Anal Away Days Launches On RealSexPass Network
General News / Thu 21st Feb 2019 Super Marios Anal Away Days Launches On RealSexPass Network Retro fan favorite Super Marios Anal Away Days launches with a new site
UKAP Advisory On HIV Production Shut Down In Europe
General News / Mon 18th Feb 2019 UKAP Advisory On HIV Production Shut Down In Europe UKAP issue advice on the HIV production shut down in Europe
The Death Of Aimee Spencer To Air On ITV
General News / Thu 7th Feb 2019 The Death Of Aimee Spencer To Air On ITV Aimee Spencer was known by the name of Carla Mai to those in the adult business that knew her. ITV have commissioned a show that looks into the events surrounding her death in 2016 with new evidence
Come Curious Celebrate All Things Sex With New Podcast
General News / Mon 4th Feb 2019 Come Curious Celebrate All Things Sex With New Podcast Florence and Reed aka The Come Curious Girls have a new podcast show discussing all things sex
Porn Actor Who Filmed Himself On Tube Train Fined £1000
General News / Mon 4th Feb 2019 Porn Actor Who Filmed Himself On Tube Train Fined £1000 Man filming porn on the London Underground with two other men is found guilty and fined £1000
Lacey Starr Launches New Site With ARLCash
General News / Fri 1st Feb 2019 Lacey Starr Launches New Site With ARLCash Award winning GILF Lacey Starr launches new site with US based ARLCash
Agents Of Porn Announce New Recruits To Their Launch Roster
General News / Thu 31st Jan 2019 Agents Of Porn Announce New Recruits To Their Launch Roster Agents Of Porn announces their new site launches
UK Revises Obscenity Laws to Allow Previously Banned Sexual Acts
General News / Thu 31st Jan 2019 UK Revises Obscenity Laws to Allow Previously Banned Sexual Acts UK revises law legalising previously banned sexual acts as legal to distribute
TELEVISION X LAUNCHES BARE KNUCKLE BOXING ON PAY-PER-VIEW
General News / Tue 22nd Jan 2019 TELEVISION X LAUNCHES BARE KNUCKLE BOXING ON PAY-PER-VIEW Leading UK adult TV channel Television X has joined forces with BKB – the only legal bare-knuckle boxing company in the world – to showcase an exclusive combat sports event.
Syphillis Alert: European Studios Shut Down Productions
General News / Tue 15th Jan 2019 Syphillis Alert: European Studios Shut Down Productions Syphillis alert prompts studios in Europe to shut down
Harmony Films Release: "Insatiable Beauties"
General News / Sat 22nd Dec 2018 Harmony Films Release: "Insatiable Beauties" Leading UK studio Harmony Films introduce new director Gilberto with "Insatiable Beauties" featuring award winning Tina Kay and Barbie Sins
Tumblr Ban Is A Sign Of Things To Come
General News / Sat 8th Dec 2018 Tumblr Ban Is A Sign Of Things To Come Whats worse than losing your social media profile? Not getting paid the money you are owed and losing all your content and followers. The Tumblr ban on porn is a reminder to not be too comfortable with social media and clip sites who are stepping up their purges on the adult industry
DVD Release: The Corruption Of Catalia Valentine
General News / Wed 5th Dec 2018 DVD Release: The Corruption Of Catalia Valentine New Brit porn release starring reknowned UK adult performer and fan favourite Catalia Valentine
Harmony Films Release Lady Dee: Sex Addict
General News / Fri 16th Nov 2018 Harmony Films Release Lady Dee: Sex Addict Harmony Films release new title in the Sex Addict series featuring Lady Dee
UK Porn Party announce the launch of Black and White Gangbangers
General News / Thu 8th Nov 2018 UK Porn Party announce the launch of Black and White Gangbangers UK Porn Party announce the launch of their latest DVD title, 'Black and White Gangbangers', now on general release.
UKAP To Address Its Position On Abuse Issues Within The Industry
General News / Sun 4th Nov 2018 UKAP To Address Its Position On Abuse Issues Within The Industry General meeting for the adult industry to discuss topics and contribute to changes moving forward. If you have anything to say then this is the place to say it. Open to all levels of adult industry but you must inform by email to attend
The UKAP Annual General Meeting Thursday November 8th
General News / Thu 25th Oct 2018 The UKAP Annual General Meeting Thursday November 8th The UKAP AGM is open to all adult industry to attend and discuss issues relating to the adult business with those who work in the adult business
BBFC To Publish Notifications Of Sites In Breach Of Age Verification
General News / Wed 17th Oct 2018 BBFC To Publish Notifications Of Sites In Breach Of Age Verification With the BBFC now receiving the guidance to take us forward we can expect age verification to begin within the first 3 months of 2019
UK Porn Podcast is back
General News / Mon 8th Oct 2018 UK Porn Podcast is back Paul Taylor of Dusk Film returns with his popular adult industry related podcast show
UKAP Announce Winners And Nominees Of UKAP Awards 2018
General News / Sun 7th Oct 2018 UKAP Announce Winners And Nominees Of UKAP Awards 2018 Results of the nominees and winners for this years UKAP Awards at Pulse in Central London on October 5th hosted by Michelle Thorne and Ryan Ryder
Naked Truth Guy In 7 Day Twitter Jail
General News / Mon 24th Sep 2018 Naked Truth Guy In 7 Day Twitter Jail Adult industry producer and advocate behind the Naked Truth podcast is gagged with a 7 Day jail sentence
The 13th Annual UKAP Awards 2018
General News / Sun 23rd Sep 2018 The 13th Annual UKAP Awards 2018 The 13th Annual UKAP Awards takes place at Pulse in Londons Blackfriars Bridge are on Friday October 5th. Why is it more than just about awards?
Industry Cyclists 24 Hour Challenge For HIV Charity
General News / Fri 14th Sep 2018 Industry Cyclists 24 Hour Challenge For HIV Charity Porn Pedallers the ramshackle bunch of adult industry performers and services cycle club ride again for their next charitable challenge: Revolve 24
World Zombie Day Hits London Saturday October 6th
General News / Thu 13th Sep 2018 World Zombie Day Hits London Saturday October 6th World Zombie Day hits London Saturday 6th after the UKAP Awards on Friday. Make the most of the fun iin London that weekend
Erigo Releases Big Titted Bukkake Girls
General News / Wed 12th Sep 2018 Erigo Releases Big Titted Bukkake Girls Erigo releases DVD Big Titted Bukkake Girls
FireCracker Films Seek Adult Industry Help For New  Project
General News / Tue 11th Sep 2018 FireCracker Films Seek Adult Industry Help For New Project Fire Cracker Films are producing an innovative new TV documentary with 5 mums who will produce their own porn movie and seek the adult industrys help in making this happen
Adult Industry Alert: Mycoplasma Genitaleum Hits UK and Europe
General News / Sat 8th Sep 2018 Adult Industry Alert: Mycoplasma Genitaleum Hits UK and Europe Two cases in UK and the Europe adult business have been revealed as Mycoplasma Genitaleum. With no testing in place for it we have no idea how many may be infected. Dont panic. Just get yourself tested at your nearest GUM . Read more here

Sign up to itsAdult as a Business or Performer to create your profile and join our ever growing community of adult industry professionals.

Forgotten your login details? Click Here

Enter your email address below

Remembered login details? Click Here