General News

PODCAST#4 RESPONSE TO THE GOVTS ANTI-PORN CONSULTATION

The government issued a consultation inviting opinion ajead of age veriification being passed into law. This is Jerrys Barnetts response.

Published Sun 3rd Apr 2016
By itsAdult / General News

PODCAST#4 RESPONSE TO THE GOVTS ANTI-PORN CONSULTATION

Response to government consultation: “Child Safety Online: Age Verification for Pornography”

This is a response to the consultation titled “Child Safety Online: Age Verification for Pornography” dated February 2016. I am the founder of the Sex & Censorship campaign, and author of the bookPorn Panic! (to be published on 26th August) which explores how recent moral panics over sex have become excuses for censorship.

Summary of Issues

There are numerous problems with the consultation document, which can be grouped into six areas:

  1. The chosen definition of “children” includes sexually-active young adults under 18.
  2. The document skilfully hides the fact that no other EU country is following the UK’s “lead” into censorship.
  3. The solution proposed would have no significant effect on the availability of sexual imagery.
  4. The evidence of harm presented is weak, cherry-picked, and ignores the strongest research, including the British government’s own research.
  5. Adequate tools for protecting small children already exist.
  6. The proposed solution would unnecessarily increase Ofcom’s censorship controls over the Internet. This is not how democratic governments are supposed to behave – especially those that lecture other nations on free expression.

Detailed Response

1 Definition of “Children”

It is customary to refer to those in the 13-17 year age group as young adults, not children. However, the government, and government regulators such as Ofcom, insist on referring to this age group as children. So the document, for example, provides the almost meaningless statement that “13% of children aged 6-14 visited an adult site in May 2015”. To talk about the behaviours of 6 year olds along with those of 14 year olds is deeply misleading: we suspect deliberately so.

We suggest that data combining small children with young adults is unsuitable for making important policy decisions and should be rejected.

2 The UK is Alone

This is far from the first UK government exercise in “protecting children from online adult content”. The UK has introduced a series of measures over more than a decade, including mobile content filters and home broadband filters. The age verification measures mentioned in this document have actually been part of UK regulation since ATVOD was established in 2010. Although we have often been told that other European countries are set to follow us, this has never happened. These measures have not been replicated anywhere else in the world. In other words, no other country sees fit to “protect its children” by introducing multiple layers of censorship.

The consultation document masks this fact, stating “It is clearly important that other nations have also been considering their own approaches to how best to protect children from potentially harmful content on the internet. However, we want to continue to lead the way.”

This statement is inaccurate. We cannot lead when no other nation is following. Going it alone is not leading. This misleading narrative hides the simple fact that no other democratic nation sees the necessity to implement expensive and draconian controls on adult content: indeed, many of the measures introduced in the UK would be unconstitutional in the United States under the first amendment, which protects free speech.

3 The Proposed Solution Would Have Little Effect

While it may succeed in changing the policies of some large, commercial content providers, the solution proposed will clearly have little to no impact on the availability of sexual material to UK consumers. As the consultation document itself points out, there are around five million adult sites in the world. Ofcom would need a huge and very expensive army of enforcers to make any dent on the availability of this material. Is this how the government intends to re-employ the estimated 40,000 people to made redundant by the collapse of the steel industry?

Alternatively, and more likely, Ofcom will come back to government in a year to point out that millions of sites are still ignoring UK law, and request further powers to block transgressors. This slippery slope of censorship is well known. Perhaps it would be better to abandon this exercise now, save time and money, and perhaps instead invest the savings in improved sex education.

4 The Evidence Offered is Weak and Cherry-Picked

The consultation document appears designed to mislead by presenting pornography as potentially harmful. In fact, not only does the growing body of research not back these claims of harm, but it in fact suggests that porn availability plays a role in reducing sexual violence. This applies especially in the case of teenagers: the very group to which the consultation aims to restrict access to sexual imagery.

The document instead cherry-picks and misrepresents the research available. Perhaps the strangest example is the following:

“There is also a question about the effect of pornography on ‘unwanted sex’ – for instance more young people are engaging in anal intercourse than ever before despite research which suggests that it is often not seen as a pleasurable activity for young women”

This is curious at several levels. The fact that some people report having anal sex, and other people report not enjoying anal sex is not evidence that anyone is being forced into anal sex as a result of pornography. Does the government really consider it its role to stop young people having anal sex? We would point out that anti-sodomy laws were removed from the British statute half a century ago and seem unlikely to return.

Most surprisingly, the document ignores the research into pornography carried out by Ofcom on behalf of the Department of Culture, Media and Sport. To remedy this omission, here are key phrases from the government’s own research.

  • “There seems to be no relationship between the availability of pornography and an increase in sex crimes in other countries; in comparison there is more evidence for the opposite effect.”
  • “Research with adults indicates no relationship between the commission of sex crimes and use of pornography at an early age. Again in comparison there is evidence for the opposite effect.”

To put this simply: the government’s own research suggests that restricting sexual imagery to teenagers may result in a rise in sexual violence among that age group. We call on the government to abandon these plans until strong evidence can be presented that they will not increase harm.

5 Adequate Tools for Protecting Children Already Exist

Parental controls for child access to the Internet have existed for over two decades. They are mature and effective: so much so that tablets are safely marketed for children by family brands such as Tesco. Regulators have repeatedly ignored this fact when lobbying for more Internet censorship controls.

But specialists believe that the most effective child protection tool of all is comprehensive sex education for all age groups. We therefore call on the government to broaden sex education, rather than attempt to keep teenagers ignorant of sexual matters until they are 18.

6 Take a Stand Against Censorship

The British government takes a strong stance against censorship in states like Iran and China. We agree with this position, and believe that free expression should be defended without compromise by the British government, in the absence of clear evidence of harm. It is unsurprising that Ofcom seeks to extend its already significant censorship powers; we expect our elected representatives to stand against a power grab by unelected regulators, and in favour of a free and open Internet for British citizens. We cannot lecture other countries on free expression while allowing ours to be continually eroded under the pretext of protecting children.

Jerry Barnett
Sex & Censorship

jerry@sexandcensorship.org

Source: SexAndCensorship.org

You May Like

What You Need To Know About The Self Employment Income Support Scheme
General News / Fri 8th May 2020 What You Need To Know About The Self Employment Income Support Scheme If you are experiencing financial difficulty because of the corona virus pandemic then you may be eligible for income support with the governments new scheme
Evil Angel Releases Angel Invades America
General News / Tue 7th Apr 2020 Evil Angel Releases Angel Invades America Angel Long is the first female producer in the UK to shoot for the quality hardcore label Evil Angel
Adult Performers Rally Support For The NHS With #WanksAsThanks Campaign
General News / Thu 2nd Apr 2020 Adult Performers Rally Support For The NHS With #WanksAsThanks Campaign Adult performers and supporters rally the industry and fans to show their appreciation for the NHS with a fund raising campaign and to ease the stress during the COVID19 crisis
Benedict Garret On Why We Must Stand Up Against Abuse
General News / Thu 2nd Apr 2020 Benedict Garret On Why We Must Stand Up Against Abuse Benedict Garrett has something personal to share about why he believes it is important to speak out against abuse where you find it
ManyVids Petitions UK Government to Safeguard Sex Workers
General News / Thu 26th Mar 2020 ManyVids Petitions UK Government to Safeguard Sex Workers ManyVids has petitioned the UK government for the occupation of “adult entertainer” to be protected under the Equality Act of 2010.
Clips4Sale Lifts Ban On Words and Sex Acts
General News / Thu 26th Mar 2020 Clips4Sale Lifts Ban On Words and Sex Acts Clips 4 Sale introduces previously banned words and sex acts as new categories to its site
UK Productions Shut Down In The Wake Of Corona Virus
General News / Sat 14th Mar 2020 UK Productions Shut Down In The Wake Of Corona Virus Productions and studios shut down in the wake of Corona Virus rise in the UK
What powers will Ofcom have to regulate the internet?
General News / Fri 13th Mar 2020 What powers will Ofcom have to regulate the internet? Watchdog to broadly oversee two specific areas covering illegal and harmful content
Filming Sex Without Consent Is A Criminal Offence
General News / Wed 29th Jan 2020 Filming Sex Without Consent Is A Criminal Offence Content producers be advised. Filming content with out the correctly worded releases giving you permission to publish online is now a criminal offence under UK law
Age Verification Industry Requests Judicial Review Regarding UK Decision
General News / Fri 17th Jan 2020 Age Verification Industry Requests Judicial Review Regarding UK Decision Top companies to the adult industry appeal against the governments decision to drop age verification
NEW DVD RELEASE: Harmony Films present Tina Kays Fetish Spa
General News / Sun 8th Dec 2019 NEW DVD RELEASE: Harmony Films present Tina Kays Fetish Spa Tina Kays second film as director for Harmony Films latest release
Open Rights Group Screening The Great Hack Across the UK
General News / Sat 30th Nov 2019 Open Rights Group Screening The Great Hack Across the UK FREE screening of the Great Hack followed by a workshop to clean up UK political campaigning.
Ride The Ribbon With Porn Pedallers
General News / Thu 31st Oct 2019 Ride The Ribbon With Porn Pedallers Porn Pedallers are inviting the adult industry to participate in a charitable event to get on your bike and Ride The Ribbon
Brit Sex Cash Gets A Site Relaunch
General News / Thu 24th Oct 2019 Brit Sex Cash Gets A Site Relaunch Popular UK pay site and affiliate program Brit Sex Cash gets a site relaunch
Govt Drop Age Verification Citing Privacy Issues
General News / Tue 22nd Oct 2019 Govt Drop Age Verification Citing Privacy Issues The government have dropped age verification
British Bukkake Productions Release Cum Faced Teens
General News / Tue 22nd Oct 2019 British Bukkake Productions Release Cum Faced Teens British Bukkake Productions release DVD Cum Faced Teens
Sahara Knite Is Elected Chair Person To Lead UKAP
General News / Mon 21st Oct 2019 Sahara Knite Is Elected Chair Person To Lead UKAP Adult performer and content producer Sahara Knite has been elected the new chair person to lead UKAP
UKAP AGM and Barge Party Friday October 18th
General News / Wed 25th Sep 2019 UKAP AGM and Barge Party Friday October 18th Information about the upcoming UKAP Annual General Meeting and party on the Tamesis Barge
Berlin Casting Call For Pascals Sub Sluts
General News / Fri 23rd Aug 2019 Berlin Casting Call For Pascals Sub Sluts Are you a performer going to Berlin for the XBiz Convention? Pascals Sub Sluts are looking for female performers seeking work
Adult Industry Friends Mourn The Loss Of Colin Chapman
General News / Sun 7th Jul 2019 Adult Industry Friends Mourn The Loss Of Colin Chapman Friends and associates mourn the loss of a dear friend and adult industry ally and advocate.
Porn Pedallers Go Large: New Sponsors, New Outfits and Epic Charity Cycle Event
General News / Fri 21st Jun 2019 Porn Pedallers Go Large: New Sponsors, New Outfits and Epic Charity Cycle Event To coincide with their Kit Launch Party in Leicester Square, Porn Pedallers announce their new sponsors, their new kit and an epic cycle event
IN FOCUS: A Film About Female Empowerment In The Adult Business
General News / Tue 18th Jun 2019 IN FOCUS: A Film About Female Empowerment In The Adult Business Lea Winchcombe is an independent film producer making a documentary about women who are empowered by what they do i the adult industry and is currently looking for female performers and content creators who want to get involved
Hardcore Guaranteed Now On Amazon Prime
General News / Wed 5th Jun 2019 Hardcore Guaranteed Now On Amazon Prime Hardcore Guaranteed is a documentary telling the untold story of UK porn pioneer Mike Freemans battle producing porn during the swinging 60s amidst police corruption and gangsters which would eventually lead to murder and the beginnings of the porn industry throughout the 80s and 90s
US Demands Social Media Details From Visa Applicants
General News / Mon 3rd Jun 2019 US Demands Social Media Details From Visa Applicants US demands visa applicants to submit their social media and emails from the past 5 years
Age Pass From AV Secure Seeks Testers
General News / Wed 22nd May 2019 Age Pass From AV Secure Seeks Testers Age verification is about to launch on June 15th and Age Pass from AV Secure is looking for candidates to help them test drive their service before launch
UKAP Awards 2019 Cancelled
General News / Tue 14th May 2019 UKAP Awards 2019 Cancelled The UKAP Awards 2019 is cancelled
Cocos Law: Online Legislation To Take Late Dubliners Name
General News / Fri 3rd May 2019 Cocos Law: Online Legislation To Take Late Dubliners Name Legislation for online bullying , stalking and revenge porn to take on the name of the Dubliner who took her own life because of cyber bullying
Harmony Films announces  New Release Kiki Neighbours
General News / Thu 18th Apr 2019 Harmony Films announces New Release Kiki Neighbours Harmony films latest DVD release Kiki Neighbours showcases Kiki Minaj, Tina Kay and Jasmine Jae among someof the talents featured o their latest release
Age Verification Of Online Porn Begins July 15th
General News / Thu 18th Apr 2019 Age Verification Of Online Porn Begins July 15th The UK government has set a date for age verification to begin on July 15th
Dusk Films Launches Nerd Pervert Merchandise
General News / Wed 10th Apr 2019 Dusk Films Launches Nerd Pervert Merchandise UK Northern based Adult Production company Dusk Films has just launched a merchandise store for its brand Nerd Pervert.

Sign up to itsAdult as a Business or Performer to create your profile and join our ever growing community of adult industry professionals.

Forgotten your login details? Click Here

Enter your email address below

Remembered login details? Click Here