General News

WHATS THE PROBLEM WITH AGE VERIFICATION?

Age verification is widely accepted among producers and webmasters as a way to prevent minors seeing inappropriate adult content, so whats the problem with it?

Published Thu 13th Oct 2016
By itsAdult / General News

WHATS THE PROBLEM WITH AGE VERIFICATION?

Last December, a law – known as AVMS 2014 – was snuck into force without a parliamentary debate. This law had two aspects: one of which was largely ignored. The part that wasn’t ignored criminalised the distribution of porn stronger than the BBFC’s tame R18 classification. This effectively outlawed the depiction of acts considered beyond-the-pale by the British establishment, even though these acts are perfectly legal to carry out in private, and provoked the memorable face-sitting protest outside Parliament.

The aspect of AVMS 2014 that the coverage largely overlooked related to age verification, making it mandatory for adult video providers to confirm that each visitor is over 18 before allowing them to see any form of explicit image or video. Arguably, this part of the law was far more significant, but on the surface seemed more reasonable. This regulation has actually been enforced by ATVOD since 2010: the 2014 law merely strengthened the existing rules.

But demanding age verification by adult service providers has far deeper implications than might be immediately obvious, and ones that inevitably have implications for the existence of an uncensored Internet.

Excluding Adults

The first problem is that, whatever the means of age verification, there will be adults that cannot get through it. Current age verification solutions include: using a credit card; providing passport or driving license details; using a mobile phone that has already been age-verified. But many adults cannot provide any of these things, and furthermore many wouldn’t want to, for privacy reasons.

Unfortunately, the UK has no strong protection against censorship, but the US does: and in America, the Supreme Court has ruled repeatedly that onerous age verification is undoubtedly censorship, so cannot be enforced by the state. So in “conservative” America, the legal system has far more problem with adults being prevented from watching porn than in “protecting children” from seeing it. The greater harm (according to the judges) is censorship, not smut: this is as America’s founding fathers intended, as they knew that censorship can be introduced for all manner of spurious reasons, and once initiated, it tends to grow.

It’s Only the UK

The AVMS regulations are laid down by the EU. But here’s the odd part: only the UK has decided that AVMS requires an expensive, activist regulator along ATVOD lines; only the UK has interpreted the AVMS scope to include adult websites (the regulations were originally designed to cover TV catch-up services); and only the UK has interpreted the regulations to mean that adult websites should implement age verification.

The Internet is Global

Here’s the real, huge problem with all this. How can regulations that only cover UK-based web businesses have any meaningful effect? There are two possible interpretations: either, that ATVOD is an expensive but powerless quango, or that the government will introduce blocking of overseas adult websites on a mass scale.

Until recently, the latter option sounded like a conspiracy theory, but during the general election campaign, the Tories announced they would be blocking sites that don’t conform to AVMS. This would require the creation of an official UK Internet censor – the first such thing in any democratic society – and probably entail the blocking of millions of sites that are considered unsuitable for children.

A “Perverts Database”

Aside from censorship, privacy is the other major concern. Age verification providers will know which sites each user is trying to access. Is it acceptable and necessary that one’s credit card provider, mobile provider or other authority could know you tried to accessBustySpankedSluts.com last Friday night?

Evangelists for age verification suggest that this problem could be averted by the creation of an “anonymising hub”. This would shield the adult site and the age verification service from each other, so that the site operator need not know your mobile number, and O2 will never know you had a wank to BustySpankedSluts.com.

But potentially, the hub multiplies the privacy issue. Now, there is a central database linking individuals to porn sites. Who would have the right to access, browse and search the database? Would the police ever have reason to request to access it? Would some alliance of hackers steal and publish data, just to prove they could, or use it for blackmail? Once this data is stored in a single place, the privacy implications are astounding.

Is a 17 Year-old a “Minor”?

ATVOD sets the age limit for accessing pornography at 18: it therefore defines 16 and 17 year olds as children, despite the age of consent being 16 in the UK. This means that debit cards can’t be used for age verification, as they can be issued to 16 year olds, and so makes age verification more onerous (many adults don’t own credit cards).

No Evidence of Harm

It’s worth a reminder at this point that the AVMS restrictions are predicated on stopping minors from viewing content that “might seriously impair” them. And yet, research carried out by Ofcom on behalf of the UK government, as well as research carried out across the European Union, is unanimous: no evidence can be found that pornography is capable of “seriously impairing”, and in fact the government’s own evidence suggests that pornography is associated with a reduction in harm. (Ofcom report – key finding is bottom page 15/top page 16).

Think of the Children!

All of this overlooks a simple fact: child protection filters are standard these days on all devices, from tablets and phones to PCs. Family brands like Tesco – which have reputations to maintain – sell their own child-friendly tablets. But such filters don’t empower or enrich regulators. Nor do they help make the case for censorship, or provide the opportunity to snoop on citizens, so they are ignored when the case for age verification is made.

While most EU authorities have thus concluded that there is no need for server-side age verification, Ofcom, ATVOD and the Department of Culture, Media and Sport have decided otherwise, and have implemented a “precautionary” system. This seems akin to fitting expensive locks to all fridges, in order to prevent teenagers freezing to death in the kitchen: it’s never happened, but you can’t prove it never will, can you?

Source: Sex & Censorship

You May Like

Porn Pedallers Go Large: New Sponsors, New Outfits and Epic Charity Cycle Event
General News / Fri 21st Jun 2019 Porn Pedallers Go Large: New Sponsors, New Outfits and Epic Charity Cycle Event To coincide with their Kit Launch Party in Leicester Square, Porn Pedallers announce their new sponsors, their new kit and an epic cycle event
IN FOCUS: A Film About Female Empowerment In The Adult Business
General News / Tue 18th Jun 2019 IN FOCUS: A Film About Female Empowerment In The Adult Business Lea Winchcombe is an independent film producer making a documentary about women who are empowered by what they do i the adult industry and is currently looking for female performers and content creators who want to get involved
Hardcore Guaranteed Now On Amazon Prime
General News / Wed 5th Jun 2019 Hardcore Guaranteed Now On Amazon Prime Hardcore Guaranteed is a documentary telling the untold story of UK porn pioneer Mike Freemans battle producing porn during the swinging 60s amidst police corruption and gangsters which would eventually lead to murder and the beginnings of the porn industry throughout the 80s and 90s
US Demands Social Media Details From Visa Applicants
General News / Mon 3rd Jun 2019 US Demands Social Media Details From Visa Applicants US demands visa applicants to submit their social media and emails from the past 5 years
Age Pass From AV Secure Seeks Testers
General News / Wed 22nd May 2019 Age Pass From AV Secure Seeks Testers Age verification is about to launch on June 15th and Age Pass from AV Secure is looking for candidates to help them test drive their service before launch
UKAP Awards 2019 Cancelled
General News / Tue 14th May 2019 UKAP Awards 2019 Cancelled The UKAP Awards 2019 is cancelled
Cocos Law: Online Legislation To Take Late Dubliners Name
General News / Fri 3rd May 2019 Cocos Law: Online Legislation To Take Late Dubliners Name Legislation for online bullying , stalking and revenge porn to take on the name of the Dubliner who took her own life because of cyber bullying
Harmony Films announces  New Release Kiki Neighbours
General News / Thu 18th Apr 2019 Harmony Films announces New Release Kiki Neighbours Harmony films latest DVD release Kiki Neighbours showcases Kiki Minaj, Tina Kay and Jasmine Jae among someof the talents featured o their latest release
Age Verification Of Online Porn Begins July 15th
General News / Thu 18th Apr 2019 Age Verification Of Online Porn Begins July 15th The UK government has set a date for age verification to begin on July 15th
Dusk Films Launches Nerd Pervert Merchandise
General News / Wed 10th Apr 2019 Dusk Films Launches Nerd Pervert Merchandise UK Northern based Adult Production company Dusk Films has just launched a merchandise store for its brand Nerd Pervert.
UK Content Creators Vote In Favour Of 28 Day Tests
General News / Fri 29th Mar 2019 UK Content Creators Vote In Favour Of 28 Day Tests UK producers, performers and clinics met up in London for the UKAP Meet & Mix to discuss various issues and voted in favour of 28 day testing
Mums Make Porn To Air  On March 20th
General News / Sun 10th Mar 2019 Mums Make Porn To Air On March 20th Mums Make Porn is a new show coming to Channel 4 that follows 4 real mums who make a porn film, cast it, direct it and produce it to make the kind of porn they would prefer their children see if they had to watch it. The series follows them through the UK adult business to the UKAP Awards 2018 to the screening of their movie in Londons West End
UKAP Meet and Mix Day Of Events 26th March
General News / Thu 7th Mar 2019 UKAP Meet and Mix Day Of Events 26th March UKAP Meet and Mix Day of events at Sanctum, Soho on Tuesday March 26th
Europe Extends Production Hold Until March 25th
General News / Thu 7th Mar 2019 Europe Extends Production Hold Until March 25th European Alliance extends production shutdown pending results of second test of first gen performers to HIV+ performer
Super Marios Anal Away Days Launches On RealSexPass Network
General News / Thu 21st Feb 2019 Super Marios Anal Away Days Launches On RealSexPass Network Retro fan favorite Super Marios Anal Away Days launches with a new site
UKAP Advisory On HIV Production Shut Down In Europe
General News / Mon 18th Feb 2019 UKAP Advisory On HIV Production Shut Down In Europe UKAP issue advice on the HIV production shut down in Europe
The Death Of Aimee Spencer To Air On ITV
General News / Thu 7th Feb 2019 The Death Of Aimee Spencer To Air On ITV Aimee Spencer was known by the name of Carla Mai to those in the adult business that knew her. ITV have commissioned a show that looks into the events surrounding her death in 2016 with new evidence
Come Curious Celebrate All Things Sex With New Podcast
General News / Mon 4th Feb 2019 Come Curious Celebrate All Things Sex With New Podcast Florence and Reed aka The Come Curious Girls have a new podcast show discussing all things sex
Porn Actor Who Filmed Himself On Tube Train Fined £1000
General News / Mon 4th Feb 2019 Porn Actor Who Filmed Himself On Tube Train Fined £1000 Man filming porn on the London Underground with two other men is found guilty and fined £1000
Lacey Starr Launches New Site With ARLCash
General News / Fri 1st Feb 2019 Lacey Starr Launches New Site With ARLCash Award winning GILF Lacey Starr launches new site with US based ARLCash
Agents Of Porn Announce New Recruits To Their Launch Roster
General News / Thu 31st Jan 2019 Agents Of Porn Announce New Recruits To Their Launch Roster Agents Of Porn announces their new site launches
UK Revises Obscenity Laws to Allow Previously Banned Sexual Acts
General News / Thu 31st Jan 2019 UK Revises Obscenity Laws to Allow Previously Banned Sexual Acts UK revises law legalising previously banned sexual acts as legal to distribute
TELEVISION X LAUNCHES BARE KNUCKLE BOXING ON PAY-PER-VIEW
General News / Tue 22nd Jan 2019 TELEVISION X LAUNCHES BARE KNUCKLE BOXING ON PAY-PER-VIEW Leading UK adult TV channel Television X has joined forces with BKB – the only legal bare-knuckle boxing company in the world – to showcase an exclusive combat sports event.
Syphillis Alert: European Studios Shut Down Productions
General News / Tue 15th Jan 2019 Syphillis Alert: European Studios Shut Down Productions Syphillis alert prompts studios in Europe to shut down
Harmony Films Release: "Insatiable Beauties"
General News / Sat 22nd Dec 2018 Harmony Films Release: "Insatiable Beauties" Leading UK studio Harmony Films introduce new director Gilberto with "Insatiable Beauties" featuring award winning Tina Kay and Barbie Sins
Tumblr Ban Is A Sign Of Things To Come
General News / Sat 8th Dec 2018 Tumblr Ban Is A Sign Of Things To Come Whats worse than losing your social media profile? Not getting paid the money you are owed and losing all your content and followers. The Tumblr ban on porn is a reminder to not be too comfortable with social media and clip sites who are stepping up their purges on the adult industry
DVD Release: The Corruption Of Catalia Valentine
General News / Wed 5th Dec 2018 DVD Release: The Corruption Of Catalia Valentine New Brit porn release starring reknowned UK adult performer and fan favourite Catalia Valentine
Harmony Films Release Lady Dee: Sex Addict
General News / Fri 16th Nov 2018 Harmony Films Release Lady Dee: Sex Addict Harmony Films release new title in the Sex Addict series featuring Lady Dee
UK Porn Party announce the launch of Black and White Gangbangers
General News / Thu 8th Nov 2018 UK Porn Party announce the launch of Black and White Gangbangers UK Porn Party announce the launch of their latest DVD title, 'Black and White Gangbangers', now on general release.
UKAP To Address Its Position On Abuse Issues Within The Industry
General News / Sun 4th Nov 2018 UKAP To Address Its Position On Abuse Issues Within The Industry General meeting for the adult industry to discuss topics and contribute to changes moving forward. If you have anything to say then this is the place to say it. Open to all levels of adult industry but you must inform by email to attend

Sign up to itsAdult as a Business or Performer to create your profile and join our ever growing community of adult industry professionals.

Forgotten your login details? Click Here

Enter your email address below

Remembered login details? Click Here